Well, it was bound to happen at some point, but with as many redemption replacements as I have done with Panini, I finally have my first repeater.
The card I replaced was a Jeremy Welsh Phenoms autograph from 2012-13 Limited. With Limited being a mid-season release, but later-released cards of Welsh being included in Prime and Dominion, I figured I wasn't going to see it any time soo, so I asked for another.
Here's what Panini sent in return:
This card is an autographed jersey card of Simon Despres from 2011-12 Certified, numbered 210/299. I first got this card back in July of 2013, as a replacement for two redemptions. These cards serve as the base rookie cards for the set and feature one large piece of fabric inside of a die-cut "ROOKIE." As I said, I already own this card, so if anyone is interested, it is up for trade, so just let me know.